Post by Host KJizzle on May 14, 2013 3:01:39 GMT -5
Ok, time for results. Your submissions have been reviewed by the judges and these are the scores.
DEENA - Bride competition
1. Originality - How original is the idea actually 1-10 - 7
2. Presentation - Did it catch my attention 1-10 - 8
3. Feasibility - Is it even possible? 1-5 - 4
4. Detail - How well did you explain the concept - 1-5 - 4
= 23
************************************************************
DEENA:
1. 7
2. 8
3. 4
4. 3
= 22
weakness is that it only describes bride's role when actually family and the groom should be included - has great potential
Total: 45
************************************************************
HEIDI - Not so Average Joe
1. Originality - 7
2. Presentation - 7
3. Feasibility - 4
4. Detail - 4
= 22
************************************************************
HEIDI:
1. 6
2. 6
3. 4
4. 5
= 21
Weakness - Unclear who the woman is and how she gets picked - and so much hinges on her
Total: 43
************************************************************
JEANNE - Becoming a Buyer
1. Originality - How original is the idea actually 1-10 - 7
2. Presentation - Did it catch my attention 1-10 - 8
3. Feasibility - Is it even possible? 1-5 - 4
4. Detail - How well did you explain the concept - 1-5 - 5
= 24
************************************************************
JEANNE:
1. 7
2. 9
3. 3
4. 5
= 24
weakness - really limited market for viewers I think -
Total: 48
************************************************************
JOANNA - Journey into the Deep
1. Originality - How original is the idea actually 1-10 - 9
2. Presentation - Did it catch my attention 1-10 - 7
3. Feasibility - Is it even possible? 1-5 0 4
4. Detail - How well did you explain the concept - 1-5 - 4
= 24
************************************************************
JOANNA:
1. 10
2. 8
3. 3
4. 3
= 24
liked this one the best - interesting concept but not explained as well as it might have been
Total: 48
************************************************************
RYAN - CLUE
1. Originality - How original is the idea actually 1-10 - 7
2. Presentation - Did it catch my attention 1-10 - 7
3. Feasibility - Is it even possible? 1-5 - 4
4. Detail - How well did you explain the concept - 1-5 - 4
= 22
************************************************************
RYAN
1. 7
2. 5
3. 5
4. 4
=21
Weakness - it's sort of another game show and part one seemed to be unrelated to clue and the picking process was not unique
Total = 43
SHAWNA - No submission
JENNA - Skip a challenge played.. she is immune this TC
So, with that, we have a tie between Jeanne and Joanna. To break the tie, we decided to go with the most ORIGINAL idea since that was basically the main crux of the challenge.
In our opinion, Joanna had the best NEW idea for a Reality Show and with a little tweaking it could be a hit with mass appeal to the public.
SO JOANNA, YOU WIN IMMUNITY! TC WILL BE UP SHORTLY
DEENA - Bride competition
1. Originality - How original is the idea actually 1-10 - 7
2. Presentation - Did it catch my attention 1-10 - 8
3. Feasibility - Is it even possible? 1-5 - 4
4. Detail - How well did you explain the concept - 1-5 - 4
= 23
************************************************************
DEENA:
1. 7
2. 8
3. 4
4. 3
= 22
weakness is that it only describes bride's role when actually family and the groom should be included - has great potential
Total: 45
************************************************************
HEIDI - Not so Average Joe
1. Originality - 7
2. Presentation - 7
3. Feasibility - 4
4. Detail - 4
= 22
************************************************************
HEIDI:
1. 6
2. 6
3. 4
4. 5
= 21
Weakness - Unclear who the woman is and how she gets picked - and so much hinges on her
Total: 43
************************************************************
JEANNE - Becoming a Buyer
1. Originality - How original is the idea actually 1-10 - 7
2. Presentation - Did it catch my attention 1-10 - 8
3. Feasibility - Is it even possible? 1-5 - 4
4. Detail - How well did you explain the concept - 1-5 - 5
= 24
************************************************************
JEANNE:
1. 7
2. 9
3. 3
4. 5
= 24
weakness - really limited market for viewers I think -
Total: 48
************************************************************
JOANNA - Journey into the Deep
1. Originality - How original is the idea actually 1-10 - 9
2. Presentation - Did it catch my attention 1-10 - 7
3. Feasibility - Is it even possible? 1-5 0 4
4. Detail - How well did you explain the concept - 1-5 - 4
= 24
************************************************************
JOANNA:
1. 10
2. 8
3. 3
4. 3
= 24
liked this one the best - interesting concept but not explained as well as it might have been
Total: 48
************************************************************
RYAN - CLUE
1. Originality - How original is the idea actually 1-10 - 7
2. Presentation - Did it catch my attention 1-10 - 7
3. Feasibility - Is it even possible? 1-5 - 4
4. Detail - How well did you explain the concept - 1-5 - 4
= 22
************************************************************
RYAN
1. 7
2. 5
3. 5
4. 4
=21
Weakness - it's sort of another game show and part one seemed to be unrelated to clue and the picking process was not unique
Total = 43
SHAWNA - No submission
JENNA - Skip a challenge played.. she is immune this TC
So, with that, we have a tie between Jeanne and Joanna. To break the tie, we decided to go with the most ORIGINAL idea since that was basically the main crux of the challenge.
In our opinion, Joanna had the best NEW idea for a Reality Show and with a little tweaking it could be a hit with mass appeal to the public.
SO JOANNA, YOU WIN IMMUNITY! TC WILL BE UP SHORTLY